Investor guide · 3 min read
Why negative earnings matter in ETF P/E
If an ETF holds 30% unprofitable companies, should those losses count when calculating the fund's P/E ratio? Many websites quietly ignore them—making risky funds look far cheaper than they really are.
The hidden bias of dropping loss-makers
Suppose you own an equal-weighted basket of two companies: Company A earns $10 million and Company B loses $5 million. Together, your basket earned $5 million in net profit.
If a website excludes Company B because its standalone P/E is negative, the website reports $10 million of profit—cutting the basket's P/E ratio in half and hiding the drag of unprofitable holdings.
Where this matters most
In mega-cap funds like S&P 500 ETFs, almost every large holding is profitable, so excluding losses barely changes the number. In US small-cap ETFs (like Russell 2000 funds), biotech, or early-stage innovation ETFs, loss-making companies can represent a large slice of the portfolio.
When combined earnings across all holdings are slightly negative, an honest look-through P/E is negative—warning you that the basket as a whole is currently losing money.
Try it on live data
- Small-Cap & Mid-Cap ETFsCompare honest look-through P/E across IWM, VB, IJR, and AVUV
- IWM vs AVUV comparisonSee how profitability screening changes small-cap P/E
Frequently asked questions
What does a negative P/E ratio on an ETF mean?
It means the combined losses of unprofitable companies in the ETF outweigh the combined profits of profitable companies over that period.
More investor guides
- How ETF P/E ratio is calculated4 min read
- Trailing vs latest-quarter P/E4 min read
- ETF holdings overlap explained4 min read
- How to compare two ETFs4 min read
- ETF Price-to-Sales (P/S) explained3 min read
Informational research
RatioFox guides explain valuation methodology in plain English and link to live calculations derived from public company filings and dated fund holdings. Informational research, not investment advice.
View all guides