Investor guide · 4 min read
How to compare two ETFs step by step
Choosing between two similar ETFs—like VOO vs QQQ, SCHD vs VYM, or VWRL vs SWDA—is much easier when you compare what is actually inside them instead of relying on their marketing names.
1. Check look-through valuation (P/E and P/S)
Start by comparing trailing P/E, latest-quarter run-rate P/E, and trailing P/S. A lower P/E and P/S means you are paying less per dollar of underlying company earnings and sales.
2. Measure holdings overlap
Check what percentage of the two funds is identical. If overlap is 85%, you are mostly choosing between slight variations of the same exposure; if overlap is 15%, the two funds behave very differently.
3. Inspect top-10 concentration and unique holdings
Two funds can both hold 500 stocks yet have very different risk if one puts 35% into its top 10 stocks and the other puts 15%. Always look at the top holdings unique to each ETF to see what extra bet you are making.
Try it on live data
- Interactive ETF Compare ToolCompare any 2 or 3 ETFs, mutual funds, or portfolios
- SCHD vs VYM comparisonWalk through a classic dividend ETF matchup
- S&P 500 ETFs categoryCompare core US index ETFs in one table
Frequently asked questions
Can I compare an ETF against a mutual fund or my own portfolio?
Yes. RatioFox's Compare tool lets you place ETFs, mutual funds, and signed-in private portfolios side by side on the exact same look-through scale.
More investor guides
- How ETF P/E ratio is calculated4 min read
- Trailing vs latest-quarter P/E4 min read
- ETF holdings overlap explained4 min read
- Negative earnings in ETF P/E3 min read
- ETF Price-to-Sales (P/S) explained3 min read
Informational research
RatioFox guides explain valuation methodology in plain English and link to live calculations derived from public company filings and dated fund holdings. Informational research, not investment advice.
View all guides