ETF vs Mutual Fund · ETF vs mutual fund

VBR vs VSIAX: Vanguard Small-Cap Value ETF vs Vanguard Morningstar Small-Cap Value Index Fund Admiral Shares

VSIAX trades at a lower trailing look-through P/E (26.40×) than VBR (28.49×). VBR and VSIAX share 90.62% of their disclosed portfolio weight across 783 overlapping holdings.

Overlap 90.62%Shared holdings 783Open VBROpen VSIAX

Side-by-side valuation and concentration

VBR vs VSIAX core valuation and concentration comparison
MetricVBRVSIAX
Trailing P/E28.49×26.40×
Latest-quarter run-rate P/E17.88×17.53×
Trailing P/S1.03×1.04×
Latest-quarter run-rate P/S0.98×0.99×
Price / NAVUS$231.38US$103.20
Disclosed holdings832816
Top-10 concentration6.04%5.70%
Effective stocks444.1439.4
Holdings dated31 August 202631 October 2026

Largest shared holdings

Largest shared holdings between VBR and VSIAX
HoldingVBR weightVSIAX weight
MRNAModerna Inc1.07%0.86%
JBLJabil Inc0.69%0.62%
ATOAtmos Energy Corp0.59%0.63%
WSMWilliams-Sonoma Inc0.57%0.64%
TPRTapestry Inc0.53%0.50%
SWSmurfit Westrock PLC0.53%0.49%
OMCOmnicom Group Inc0.53%0.48%
THCTenet Healthcare Corp0.49%0.48%
USFDUS FOODS HOLDING CORP COM0.49%0.48%
EXEExpand Energy Corp0.50%0.45%

Top holdings in VBR not in VSIAX

  • EMEEMCOR Group Inc · 0.35%
  • ILMNILLUMINA INC · 0.33%
  • FLEXFLEX LTD · 0.21%
  • CNHCNH Industrial NV · 0.20%
  • ITTITT Inc · 0.19%

Top holdings in VSIAX not in VBR

  • TSNTYSON FOODS INC CLASS A · 0.17%
  • WSOWATSCO · 0.12%
  • MMEDMINIMED GROUP INC COM · 0.11%
  • UCBUCB SA · 0.10%
  • CNMCORE & MAIN INC CL A · 0.09%

Frequently asked questions

What is the holdings overlap between VBR and VSIAX?

VBR and VSIAX share 90.62% of their disclosed portfolio weight across 783 overlapping holdings.

Which has a lower P/E ratio: VBR or VSIAX?

VSIAX trades at a lower trailing look-through P/E (26.40×) than VBR (28.49×). VBR holds 832 disclosed positions compared with 816 in VSIAX.

How does ratio/fox calculate VBR and VSIAX valuation ratios?

ratio/fox aggregates market value, signed ordinary shareholder earnings, and revenue across disclosed holdings before calculating each fund's look-through P/E and P/S.

Related comparisons

Sources and notes

Comparison metrics are calculated from dated issuer holdings disclosures and primary company financial filings, normalised to USD. Informational research, not investment advice.

VBR full valuation VSIAX full valuation