Factors · ETF comparison

QUAL vs MOAT: iShares MSCI USA Quality Factor ETF vs VanEck Morningstar Wide Moat ETF

MOAT trades at a lower trailing look-through P/E (23.14×) than QUAL (23.92×). QUAL and MOAT share 11.82% of their disclosed portfolio weight across 14 overlapping holdings.

Overlap 11.82%Shared holdings 14Open QUALOpen MOAT

Side-by-side valuation and concentration

QUAL vs MOAT core valuation and concentration comparison
MetricQUALMOAT
Trailing P/E23.92×23.14×
Latest-quarter run-rate P/E22.49×20.82×
Trailing P/S4.49×3.13×
Latest-quarter run-rate P/S4.25×3.00×
PriceUS$51.87US$109.58
Disclosed holdings12756
Top-10 concentration44.51%25.32%
Effective stocks35.950.1
Holdings dated19 August 202630 June 2026

Largest shared holdings

Largest shared holdings between QUAL and MOAT
HoldingQUAL weightMOAT weight
NVDANVIDIA Corp6.21%2.45%
AMATApplied Materials Inc2.97%2.34%
MSFTMicrosoft Corp7.31%2.20%
METAMeta Platforms Inc3.54%1.17%
FTNTFortinet Inc1.07%2.21%
CMGChipotle Mexican Grill Inc0.90%1.42%
SCHWCharles Schwab Corp/The0.50%2.45%
MSIMotorola Solutions Inc0.44%1.24%
PEPPepsiCo Inc0.36%1.17%
ZTSZoetis Inc0.14%1.82%

Top holdings in QUAL not in MOAT

  • AAPLApple Inc · 6.68%
  • LLYEli Lilly & Co · 4.00%
  • LRCXLam Research Corp · 3.59%
  • TJXTJX Cos Inc/The · 3.58%
  • GOOGLAlphabet Inc · 3.47%

Top holdings in MOAT not in QUAL

  • MASMASCO · 2.96%
  • KVUEKenvue Inc · 2.59%
  • ABNBAirbnb Inc · 2.56%
  • PANWPalo Alto Networks Inc · 2.51%
  • BF.BBrown-Forman Corp · 2.49%

Frequently asked questions

What is the holdings overlap between QUAL and MOAT?

QUAL and MOAT share 11.82% of their disclosed portfolio weight across 14 overlapping holdings.

Which has a lower P/E ratio: QUAL or MOAT?

MOAT trades at a lower trailing look-through P/E (23.14×) than QUAL (23.92×). QUAL holds 127 disclosed positions compared with 56 in MOAT.

How does ratio/fox calculate QUAL and MOAT valuation ratios?

ratio/fox aggregates market value, signed ordinary shareholder earnings, and revenue across disclosed holdings before calculating each fund's look-through P/E and P/S.

Related comparisons

Sources and notes

Comparison metrics are calculated from dated issuer holdings disclosures and primary company financial filings, normalised to USD. Informational research, not investment advice.

QUAL full valuation MOAT full valuation